Should We Leave Cameras on During Video Lectures?
by Cindy Nebel
Image from Pixabay
In a world of virtual learning, there have been many considerations about whether students should be required to keep their videos on or off while in class. There have been debates centered around issues of privacy and equity related to students displaying their home environments or broadband connectivity differences. Some have also argued that seeing oneself on screen can increase monitoring of our appearance and leads to increased zoom fatigue.
On the other hand, students report that seeing their classmates creates a better sense of connection and leads to better engagement and learning. It can also lead to more accountability as both the instructor and peers can see off-task behaviors.
While the reasons above for perhaps keeping cameras off are legitimate, the question of whether or not keeping them on or off benefits learning is mostly theoretical or anecdotal. There is very little empirical evidence on this topic. However, one recent study investigated exactly this issue (1).
Image from Pixabay
Researchers had all participants watch a video lecture on Zoom and then take a quiz. The participants were split into three conditions. Group 1 had all screens off (no one in the class could see themselves or anyone else). Group 2 had only their own screen off (they could see the rest of the class). Group 3 had screens on (they could see themselves and others).
If seeing others is distracting or causes anxiety because of equity issues, then Groups 2 and 3 should be negatively affected. If seeing yourself causes Zoom fatigue because of monitoring, then Group 3 should be really affected. But if, instead, seeing others increases engagement, then Groups 2 and 3 should do a bit better and if seeing yourself increases accountability then Group 3 should do a lot better.
It should be noted that there might be multiple different effects at play here. What these researchers were asking was not about the why this happens. They were asking if there is a difference first.
The lecture itself was part of an introductory psychology course and was pre-recorded. The instructor was unfamiliar to the students and was not visible on screen. After about a half hour lecture, the students were told to immediately switch over to their LMS to take the 15-item multiple-choice quiz.
The researchers found that those students who could see themselves and their peers scored highest on the quiz and significantly higher than those who had video off.
Data from cited study
What this indicates is that asking students to keep their videos on is probably ok and it might actually be helpful. But there are some major limitations to this study. The issues of equity described above are not, in any way, addressed as part of this study. It is very possible that significant individual differences exist for who will benefit from having video on. As I explained above, this also doesn’t really give us an answer for why we see this effect. There are a lot of reasons why seeing others and yourself could be beneficial and understanding why is important to determine when this effect will persist.
There were also some really artificial things about this experiment. If engagement and feelings of connectedness drive this effect, then seeing the instructor and having a relationship with that individual would likely boost these results considerably. Having taught solely online for 3 full years now, I feel confident saying that the student experience is enhanced when we can see each other. I see reactions and can adjust my discussion or review concepts in real time, knowing when there is confusion, surprise, etc. These factors weren’t tested in the current study, but likely increase the effects seen here.
What does this mean for you:
As an educator, consider encouraging (but perhaps not requiring) students to keep their cameras on. It likely will not hurt their learning in a significant way.
I would, on a personal note, recommend that you acknowledge that there are many reasons why someone might turn their video off on a certain day or that they might want to leave it off all the time for a particular reason… and that’s ok. In my own courses, I ask everyone to keep them on as part of behavioral norms at the beginning of the course and to let me know if there is a reason why they cannot. There are a LOT of reasons why students like to keep their cameras off occasionally, and I respect them.
As a student, turn on your camera during synchronous sessions, but also consider how you behave in asynchronous sessions. These data suggest that when learning from video, it’s likely beneficial to have some peers with you. Maybe consider having a watch party so you can all get together, eat some popcorn, and watch your lecture! Or jump on zoom and have someone share screen so you can all watch together and see yourself too! (Popcorn optional.)
Reference:
(1) Austin, M. R., Fogler, K. A., & Daniel, D. B. (2021). Seeing self and others on-screen does not negatively impact learning in virtual classrooms. Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Psychology, Advance Online Publication.
